Not what you're
looking for? Try an advanced search.
Buy This Entire Record For
Church v. Back
April 22, 2010
MOUNT HOPE CHURCH, PLAINTIFF,
BASH BACK!, ET AL., DEFENDANTS.
The opinion of the court was delivered by: Hon. Robert Holmes Bell
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
This matter is before the Court on Plaintiff's motion for a protective order to keep Plaintiff's witnesses anonymous. (Dkt. No. 79.) Defendants have not filed a response to this motion, although the time period for responding has expired.
Several circuits have held that anonymity is appropriate where the need for anonymity outweighs prejudice to the opposing party and the public's interest in knowing the individual's identity. Does I thru XXIII v. Advanced Textile Corp., 214 F.3d 1058, 1068 (9th Cir. 2000) (citing cases from various federal circuit courts). The need for anonymity arises "when identification creates a risk of retaliatory physical or mental harm." Id. Plaintiff presents evidence that Defendant Bash Back and its supporters have directed threats and intimidating language towards individuals and organizations that have come forward in support of Plaintiff. For example, one e-mail from Bash Back can be read to encourage the vandalism of the Arizona office of the Alliance Defense Fund, the organization representing Plaintiff in this matter. (Dkt. No. 81 Ex. 4.) In addition, after state representative Dave Agema publicly expressed disapproval of the disruption of religious services, a Bash Back supporter suggested that representative Agema should "watch [his] f***ing back." (Dkt. No. 81 Ex. 6.) The Court is satisfied that Plaintiff has introduced sufficient evidence that its witnesses face a credible threat of retaliation if they are required to testify openly in support of Plaintiff, and that the anonymity of Plaintiff's witnesses is appropriate.*fn1
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Plaintiff's motion for a protective order to keep Plaintiff's witnesses anonymous (Dkt. No. 79) is GRANTED. Plaintiff will assign to each of its witnesses a number, one through one-hundred. Plaintiff will file with the Court under seal a spreadsheet containing the true identity of each witness and the number that has been assigned to the witness. Defendants' counsel of record shall be permitted to view the spreadsheet upon adequately representing to the Court that, as an officer of the Court, Defendants' counsel will maintain the confidentiality of the true identities of Plaintiff's witnesses. Throughout the course of these proceedings, Plaintiff's witnesses shall be required to disclose the city in which they reside, but they will not be required to disclose any information that could jeopardize their anonymity.
ROBERT HOLMES BELL UNITED STATES ...
Buy This Entire Record For